12 September 2025
When your vehicle’s engine fails, it’s a big deal—and an even bigger cost. Whether you’re running a family SUV, a commercial truck, or your personal daily driver, the decision between buying a new engine or a used one isn’t just about price—it’s about long-term reliability, budget, and practicality.
In this article, we’ll help you weigh the pros and cons of new vs. used engines, understand what really matters when choosing one, and explain why many drivers in Calgary turn to Western Auto & Truck Parts for quality recycled engines that actually last.
Key Takeaways
- A used engine can save you thousands without sacrificing quality—if sourced from a trusted parts dealer.
- New engines are ideal when warranties and longevity outweigh cost concerns.
- Not all used engines are equal—mileage, testing, and supplier reputation matter most.
- Western Auto & Truck Parts in Calgary offers fully inspected recycled engines backed by expert guidance and real savings.
What Happens When Your Engine Fails?
Most people don’t plan for engine failure. It can feel like your vehicle went from “fine” to “dead” overnight. But engines often fail due to years of wear, overheating, low oil pressure, or internal component breakdown.
So once a mechanic confirms your engine’s toast, you’ve got three main options:
- Buy a brand new engine from the manufacturer.
- Rebuild or remanufacture your existing engine.
- Buy a used (recycled) engine from a reputable auto parts supplier.
Let’s break those down—focusing mostly on the used vs. new decision.
Cost Comparison: Used Engine vs. New Engine
New Engines
- Price Range: $4,000–$10,000+
- Best For: Newer vehicles, dealership repairs, high-end performance
- Pros: Full warranty, zero prior wear, peace of mind
- Cons: Extremely expensive, often costs more than the value of the car
Used Engines
- Price Range: $800–$3,500
- Best For: Older vehicles, tight budgets, practical repairs
- Pros: Big savings, immediate availability, eco-friendly
- Cons: Unknown history (if not properly vetted), shorter warranty
Common Myths About Used Engines
A lot of people hesitate to buy used engines because of old misconceptions. Let’s clear a few up:
“Used engines are unreliable.”
Not necessarily. When sourced from a specialized parts dealer like Western Auto & Truck Parts, used engines are often low-mileage units from insurance write-offs or import stock, thoroughly tested and ready to run.
“Used engines don’t last long.”
With proper care, a used engine can easily outlast the rest of the vehicle. It depends more on how the engine was maintained before it was pulled—and how it’s installed.
“You don’t get a warranty.”
Good suppliers do offer warranties—Western Auto & Truck Parts includes warranty options and clear documentation for peace of mind.
What to Look for in a Used Engine
Before you buy a used engine, here’s what matters most:
1. Mileage
Look for engines with lower mileage (ideally under 150,000 km) to get more life out of the unit.
2. Compression Test Results
Reliable parts dealers test engine compression to ensure cylinders are functioning properly.
3. Clean VIN Matching
It’s critical to match the engine to your vehicle’s make, model, and year to avoid compatibility issues.
4. Dealer Reputation
Buy from a business that specializes in recycled auto parts, not just a random listing. Western Auto & Truck Parts has built a reputation in Calgary for quality control and reliable sourcing.
Situations Where Buying a Used Engine Makes Sense
✅ Budget Repairs on Older Vehicles
If your car’s worth $5,000 and a new engine costs $7,000, it doesn’t make sense. A recycled engine lets you keep your vehicle running without breaking the bank.
✅ Temporary Vehicle Fix
Need your work truck to run for another 2 years? A used engine can get you there for a fraction of the cost.
✅ Environmentally Friendly Option
Recycling engines keeps massive amounts of metal, oil, and parts out of landfills. It’s a sustainable option with real impact.
When a New Engine Might Be Worth It
There are still times when a brand-new engine is the smarter choice:
- Your vehicle is under warranty or part of a manufacturer program
- You need long-term performance in harsh conditions (e.g., commercial fleet)
- You’re restoring a rare or collectible vehicle
In these cases, the high cost might pay off over the long haul. But for most everyday drivers in Calgary? A used engine offers the best mix of cost, reliability, and speed.
Why Calgary Drivers Trust Western Auto & Truck Parts
Western Auto & Truck Parts isn't just a salvage yard. It’s a specialized recycled parts supplier with years of experience matching the right engine to the right vehicle.
Here’s what sets them apart:
- Thorough inspections and testing
- Helpful team who explains what you’re buying
- Inventory for domestic and imported vehicles
- Warranty options for added protection
- Located right in Calgary for local pickup or fast delivery
What to Ask Before Buying a Used Engine
Before you buy, ask these 5 questions:
- What’s the mileage on the engine?
- Has it been compression tested?
- Do you offer a warranty?
- Is it compatible with my VIN?
- Can I return it if it doesn’t fit?
If the seller hesitates to answer—walk away. But with a team like Western Auto & Truck Parts, these answers come standard.
Final Thoughts: Should You Buy a Used Engine?
In most everyday situations—commuter vehicles, older cars, work trucks—a used engine makes a lot of sense. You’ll save money, avoid wasting a perfectly good vehicle, and get back on the road faster.
But it only works if you buy smart. That means going with a trusted parts supplier who knows their inventory, tests their parts, and actually supports you after the sale.
In Calgary, that’s Western Auto & Truck Parts.
Next Step: Get Expert Help Choosing the Right Engine
If you’re considering a used engine for your car or truck, reach out to Western Auto & Truck Parts in Calgary. Their team will help you find the right engine, explain your warranty options, and make sure you feel confident about your decision.
Not finding what you were looking for?
Western Auto and Truck Parts is here to assist. Well-known for our extensive selection of used engines, differentials, and auto body parts at competitive prices, we also specialize in providing high-quality used automotive glass and more. Whether you're searching for a rare component or need advice on the best options for your vehicle, our knowledgeable staff is dedicated to helping you find the perfect solution. Don't hesitate to reach out or visit us for personalized assistance and explore our comprehensive inventory for all your automotive needs.
HERE ARE WESTERN AUTO AND TRUCK PARTS’ TOP RESOURCES ON BUYING AUTO PARTS:
SEARCH
Looking for our Edmonton location? Click Here